The Best Plan Possible – Especially Considering the Alternative

If You Ever Want Broadband, You Must Vote on Tuesday

As you consider the merits of the upcoming vote at the Nov 18 special town meeting, there is one overarching and sweeping factor that we must all grapple with:

Princeton is the largest “unserved” community in the state of Massachusetts for broadband internet. [source]

That’s one of the least appealing labels you would want associated with your town if:

  • You are a homeowner and are counting on your property to increase in value.
  • You are a parent with school age children and want them to have broadband for school before they graduate.
  • You own a small business or you have a career that depends upon working from home with reliable, fast internet.

The Nov 18 vote will determine, once and for all, whether or not we as a community have the will and progressiveness to change that fact.

nov18So What Happens if the Nov 18 Vote Does Not Pass?

On this site, we have talked on the merits of the Matrix plan and the rationale for the request to borrow for the “make ready” costs. We have talked about why our community needs reliable broadband for working from home, school, entertainment – as well as pragmatically for home valuations.

But we have not said much about what happens if the Nov 18 vote does not pass by 2/3rds majority.

Simply put, the ramifications are sweeping, severe, and unforgiving:

First, Matrix’s offer to pay for the entire network construction (that’s 73% of the whole project cost) will be terminated. Matrix will move onto other unserved communities in Western Massachusetts and elsewhere.

Second, we will seriously damage our chances of getting a state grant to pay for the “make ready” costs. Princeton has a possible opportunity to get some/all of our “make ready” costs paid for through the recently passed IT Bond Bill. However, in our discussions with state officials, it is clear that “skin in the game” is a key determinant in the division of funds to the 26 unserved towns. A NO vote would show that we have no “skin in the game” at all and would put us in the back of the line.

Third, in the end, we will continue to be the largest “unserved” community in the state of Massachusetts for the indefinite future.

The Best Possible Plan for Our Unique Circumstances

Maybe there’s aspects of the Matrix plan that you would like to change. Maybe you think a better option will come down the pike if we just wait.

But we should all be very careful with basing our vote on quibbles with the plan or dreams of a knight in shining armor just around the corner. There are no Plan B’s. There are no other suitors waiting in the wings. Comcast, Charter, and Verizon have even gone so far as to formally decline an offer to come into town. And, doing it ourselves would cost taxpayers over three times more than the Matrix plan would.

The broadband committee has been working on a solution to present to the town for two years. We have wrestled with every conceivable broadband technology, engaged many vendors, and assessed every possible financial solution. When you factor in the state of the telecom/cable industry and the unique demographics and geography of our town, each committee member will say unequivocally that the Matrix private/public plan is the best plan possible for our community.

Compared to any imaginable alternative, the Matrix plan significantly reduces our tax burden, minimizes our town’s risk, maximizes services to the entire town (not just the most densely populated areas), and is future proofed for generations to come.

Let’s do this Princeton.

Advertisements

8 comments

  1. Brian

    Thank you for this information and thanks to the whole committee for pulling this together! I look forward to voting “yes” on Tuesday, and will continue urging others to do the same!

  2. dixfdavis@aol.com

    We certainly will be at the meeting on the 18th with our fingers crossed for a positive outcome. Dix and Sarah Davis

  3. Pingback: Getting Ready for Tuesday’s Vote | Princeton Broadband
  4. Phil Gransewicz

    Two more YES votes here as well. We’d be crazy to pass up the possibility of getting some of the make ready costs reimbursed by the state. I doubt we’d ever get that opportunity again.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s